Panera pilots points: MyPanera evolves with tiered rewards choice-driven redemption

Panera pilots points: MyPanera evolves with tiered rewards choice-driven redemption

Panera Bread is testing an elevated, points-based MyPanera program, shifting away from its traditional "surprise and delight" model toward a more transparent, currency-based system.

The test covers 216 locations in Chicago, Dallas, Denver, Seattle and Wyoming. Reaching nearly 4 million MyPanera members, the pilot is designed to offer guests more control over how they earn and spend their rewards.

The power of 10

Under the new structure, guests earn 10 points for every dollar spent. This shift to a transparent point-per-dollar ratio brings MyPanera in line with other heavy hitters in the space, like Starbucks and Chipotle, giving members a clear roadmap to their next reward.

The hallmark of this upgrade is choice. Rather than waiting for a specific automated reward, guests choose how to redeem their points across a variety of tiers:

  • Small Wins: Quick redemptions for items like a free bagel or an extra side.
  • The Main Event: Accumulating points for higher-value items like full sandwiches or salads.
  • The program also leans heavily into data-driven personalization, introducing "bonus point moments" and tailored offers based on individual guest preferences.

Introducing MyPanera+

Perhaps the most significant strategic move in this pilot is the introduction of MyPanera+, an exclusive tier designed to reward Panera's most loyal "super-users."

Access to MyPanera+ is granted to:

  • Subscribers of the Unlimited Sip Club.
  • Guests who spend $300 or more annually.

The rollout timeline

The testing phase begins in Dallas on Jan. 28, with the Chicago, Denver, Seattle and Wyoming markets going live on Feb. 4.

While this is a pilot program, Panera executives, led by Chief Digital Officer Meenakshi Nagarajan, are eyeing a broader national rollout later in 2026.

For a brand that was an early pioneer in the digital loyalty space, this pivot to a points-based system signals a new chapter in Panera's effort to remain the "king of the morning" and a dominant force in the lunchtime rush.

CATEGORIES: Restaurants

RELATED CONTENT

Popular Rewards

MORE Restaurant Rewards